Blizzard-Bound? Here Are 5 Underrated Netflix Gems to Watch While You’re Snowed In

As the Northeast braces for what could be a record-breaking blizzard, New Yorkers are scrambling to stock up on essentials—but there’s one crucial survival kit item that often gets overlooked: great entertainment. When you’re stuck inside with nothing but the sound of howling winds and the sight of snow piling up outside your window, you’ll want something truly binge-worthy to keep you company.

I’ve scoured Netflix for hidden treasures that deserve more love—shows that might not be trending but offer some of the most compelling storytelling you’ll find anywhere. These aren’t your typical mainstream picks; they’re the kind of series that will make you forget you’re even snowed in.

“Karma” – A Twisted Tale of Consequences

What goes around comes around in this addictive mystery thriller that had me glued to my screen from start to finish. The premise is deceptively simple: six strangers find their lives entangled after a devastating car accident, but what unfolds is anything but straightforward.

Each character is wrestling with the fallout of their worst decisions, and as their stories collide, the consequences spiral in ways that are both shocking and satisfying. Not everyone in this ensemble is easy to root for, which makes the tension even more delicious. If you’re looking for a show that keeps you guessing until the very end, this one delivers in spades.

“Long Story Short” – A Family Saga Across Decades

From Raphael Bob-Waksberg, the creator of “BoJack Horseman,” comes this surprisingly grounded slice-of-life family sitcom that quietly unfolds across decades. Following the Schwooper family—siblings Avi, Shira, and Yoshi—each episode jumps to a different pivotal moment in their increasingly disjointed lives.

What makes this show special is how it builds a complete picture of a family through seemingly disconnected snapshots. The emotional payoff in the final episodes is genuinely moving, and I found myself reaching for tissues more than once. With Season 2 already confirmed, now’s the perfect time to get acquainted with the Schwooper clan.

“Midnight Mass” – Horror That Hits Different

I’ll admit I’m stretching the definition of “underrated” here since Mike Flanagan is behind some of Netflix’s biggest horror hits. But for some reason, “Midnight Mass” doesn’t get the same love as “The Haunting of Hill House” or “The Fall of the House of Usher,” and that’s a shame.

Set on an isolated fishing community, this slow-burn horror masterpiece follows recovering alcoholic Riley Finn as he returns home to find the town revitalized by the arrival of Father Paul, a charismatic priest whose miracles come with a sinister twist. Hamish Linklater’s performance as Father Paul is nothing short of mesmerizing, and the way all the character arcs converge is some of the most satisfying storytelling you’ll find in the genre.

“Beef” – When Road Rage Spirals Out of Control

This dark comedy follows what happens when a minor road rage incident between two strangers—played brilliantly by Steven Yeun and Ali Wong—escalates into an all-consuming feud that threatens to destroy both their lives.

What starts as a simple case of “I can’t believe that person cut me off” transforms into a complex exploration of anger, regret, and the ways we sabotage ourselves. The writing is razor-sharp, the performances are phenomenal, and the show manages to be both hilarious and deeply uncomfortable in the best possible way.

“The Chair” – Academia Never Looked So Good

Sandra Oh stars as Dr. Ji-Yoon Kim, the first woman of color to chair the English department at a prestigious university that’s struggling to stay relevant. What follows is a sharp, witty look at the challenges of academia, generational divides, and the politics of trying to modernize an institution that’s resistant to change.

The show packs a lot into its six episodes—touching on everything from cancel culture to the challenges of being a single parent—without ever feeling preachy or heavy-handed. It’s the perfect blend of smart humor and genuine heart.

Stream “Karma” on Netflix now

Stream “Long Story Short” on Netflix now

Stream “Midnight Mass” on Netflix now

Trending Tags: #BlizzardBinge #SnowDayEntertainment #NetflixHiddenGems #WinterMustWatch #StayInsideAndStream #BingeWorthy #UnderratedShows #SnowedInSurvivalGuide #NetflixAndChill #Blizzard2024

Viral Phrases: “Snowed in? Netflix has your back!” “Forget the shovel, grab the remote!” “These shows are hot enough to melt the snow!” “Binge your way through the blizzard!” “Netflix and actually chill this winter!” “Your snow day just got a whole lot better!” “Who needs a snowplow when you’ve got these gems?” “The only thing deeper than the snow is these storylines!” “Make your blizzard binge legendary!” “Winter is coming… and so is your next obsession!”

,